2024 Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevrolet Colorado

Toyota Tacoma vs Chevrolet Colorado at Germain Toyota of Columbus

When it comes to midsize pickup trucks, no other nameplate has dominated the segment quite like the legendary Toyota Tacoma. Its award-winning reputation for quality and durability, proven performance capabilities, and rugged good looks are just a handful of reasons why the Tacoma continues to top the competition. To help further demonstrate how the Tacoma remains the top choice in its class, our team at Germain Toyota Columbus has assembled this head-to-head comparison against the Chevrolet Colorado. Which one will be the better option for your lifestyle and needs? After you see the results, we have a feeling that you’ll choose the Tacoma.

Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevrolet Colorado

Toyota Tacoma Exterior Chevrolet Colorado Exterior
2024 Toyota Tacoma SR5 I4 4X4 Double Cab VS 2024 Chevrolet Colorado LT 4X4 V6 Crew Cab
$41,895 Starting MSRP (including destination charges)* $36,795
2.4L Turbocharged I4 – 278 HP / 317 LB-FT TQ ✓ Engine / Horsepower / Torque 2.7L Turbocharged I4 – 237 HP / 260 LB-FT TQ
24 ✓ Highway MPG** 23
6,400 lbs ✓ Max Towing Capacity 3,500 lbs
Double Wishbone / Multi-Link ✓ Front/Rear Suspension Short/Long Arm / Leaf
Standard ✓ Blind Spot Monitoring Optional
Standard ✓ Adaptive Cruise Control Optional
Standard ✓ Heated Exterior Mirrors Optional
LED ✓ Headlight/Taillight Type Halogen
Power 2-Way ✓ Driver Power Lumbar Support Not Available
Standard ✓ Auto-Dimming Rearview Mirror Optional
2 Years / 25,000 Miles ✓ Complimentary Scheduled Maintenance 1 Year / 12,000 Miles

Although the Chevrolet Colorado begins this matchup with a slight price advantage, smart shoppers will quickly understand the sacrifices they’ll be making by choosing the Colorado over the Toyota Tacoma. For fairness’ sake, we’ve taken equivalent trim levels equipped with similar cab configurations and powertrains.

Especially important for truck buyers the Tacoma offers more power and a much, much better towing capacity. Perhaps even more impressive is the fact that the Tacoma manages to deliver a higher highway MPG fuel economy rating** than the Colorado despite its significant power advantage. Compared to the bouncy and unrefined ride of the leaf springs found on the Colorado, the Tacoma offers a smooth ride on the road thanks to its multi-link rear suspension design.

Toyota Tacoma Towing

Other premium standard features found on the exterior of the Toyota Tacoma SR5 V6 include heated exterior mirrors and LED exterior lighting for superior visibility. Inside the cabin, drivers will also enjoy the benefits and convenience of an automatic dimming rearview mirror. If you desire any of these features on the Colorado, get ready to step up to a far more expensive trim level. Tacoma buyers will also enjoy the 2-way power adjustable driver’s seat power lumbar that comes with the SR5, especially when compared to the more limited manual adjustment options in the Colorado.

Toyota puts a big emphasis on safety and that’s why you’ll see that the Tacoma comes standard with a blind spot monitoring system and adaptive cruise control. Last but not least, Toyota includes 2 years or 25,000 miles of complimentary scheduled maintenance with the purchase of a new Tacoma. That’s a full year longer than what you’ll get at Chevrolet.

Toyota Tacoma Interior

Winner — Toyota Tacoma

Now that we’ve seen the results, it’s clear that the obvious winner of this in-depth comparison is the Toyota Tacoma. The Chevrolet Colorado simply cannot compete with the exceptional value, capability, premium standard equipment, and cutting-edge safety features found on the Toyota Tacoma. As you can see, there’s a reason that the Tacoma has remained the top choice in the segment for over a decade. Ready to write your own chapter in the storied history of the Tacoma? Our team at Germain Toyota of Columbus is standing by to help you find the right Tacoma model for your lifestyle.

*Starting MSRP includes the Delivery, Processing and Handling of $1,095 for Cars (Corolla, Corolla HV, Corolla HB, GR Corolla, Camry, Camry HV, Prius, Prius Prime, Toyota Crown, Mirai, GR86, GR Supra), $1,350 for Entry SUV/Small SUV (Corolla Cross, Corolla Cross HV, RAV4, RAV4 HV, RAV4 Prime, bZ4X), $1,395 for Mid SUV/Van (4Runner, Venza, Highlander, Highlander HV, Grand Highlander, Grand Highlander HV, Sienna), $1,495 for Small Pickup (Tacoma), $1,850 for Large Pickup/Large SUV (Tundra, Tundra HV, Sequoia). (Historically, vehicle manufacturers and distributors have charged a separate fee for processing, handling and delivering vehicles to dealerships. Toyota’s charge for these services is called the “Delivery, Processing and Handling” and is based on the value of the processing, handling and delivery services Toyota provides as well as Toyota’s overall pricing structure and may be subject to change at any time. Toyota may make a profit on the Delivery, Processing and Handling.) The Delivery, Processing and Handling in AL, AR, FL, GA, LA, MS, NC, OK, SC and TX may vary. The published prices do not apply to Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Dealer price will vary.

**2024 projected EPA-estimated mpg rating estimates as determined by manufacturer. EPA estimates not available at time of posting. Use for comparison purposes only. Your mileage will vary for many reasons, including your vehicle’s condition and how/where you drive. See www.fueleconomy.gov.